edited
4th Jul 2024
Nature Positive (Environment Protection Australia) Bill 2024 and two others - Second Reading - Criticism of bills
Bert Van Manen voted No
Tanya Plibersek voted No
Not passed by a large majority
No rebellions 68% attendance
Bert Van Manen and Tanya Plibersek have voted the same way 1% of the time
Bert Van Manen
Liberal Party Representative for Forde since August 2010
Tanya Plibersek
Australian Labor Party Representative for Sydney since October 1998
Since August 2010 Bert Van Manen and Tanya Plibersek have voted in the same division 2072 times.
In divisions they have voted differently 2042 times. They have only voted the same 30 times.
How do their votes on policies compare?
Policies are groups of votes related to an issue. We only show policies where we have enough information on both people.
Always voted the same way on
Voted a mixture of the same and differently on
- Climate change mitigation strategies (e.g., carbon capture and storage)
- Making the cashless debit card program voluntary and not mandatory
- Protecting Australian sovereignty in trade agreements
- Restricting foreign ownership
- Speeding things along in Parliament (procedural)
- Suspending the rules to allow a vote to happen (procedural)
Always voted differently on
- A carbon price
- A character test for Australian visas
- A citizenship test
- A combined Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia
- A minerals resource rent tax
- A plebiscite on the carbon pricing mechanism
- A Royal Commission into Violence and Abuse against People with Disability
- A same-sex marriage plebiscite
- A transition plan for coal workers
- An Australian Building and Construction Commission (ABCC)
- An emissions reduction fund
- Banning mobiles and other devices in immigration detention
- Building dedicated quarantine facilities (COVID-19)
- Carbon farming
- Charging postgraduate research students fees
- Civil celebrants having the right to refuse to marry same-sex couples
- Compensating victims of overseas terrorism since the September 11 attack
- Considering legislation to create a federal anti-corruption commission (procedural)
- Decreasing availability of welfare payments
- Decreasing the private health insurance rebate
- Deregulating undergraduate university fees
- Doctor-initiated medical transfers for asylum seekers
- Drug testing welfare recipients
- Encouraging Australian-based industry
- Ending illegal logging
- Federal action on public housing
- Getting rid of Sunday and public holiday penalty rates
- Government administered paid parental leave
- Greater control over items brought into immigration detention centres
- Implementing refugee and protection conventions
- Increasing access to the JobKeeper Payment
- Increasing competition in bulk wheat export
- Increasing consumer protections
- Increasing eligibility requirements for Australian citizenship
- Increasing fishing restrictions
- Increasing funding for road infrastructure
- Increasing funding for university education
- Increasing housing affordability
- Increasing indexation of HECS-HELP debts
- Increasing investment in renewable energy
- Increasing or removing the Government debt limit
- Increasing penalties for breach of data
- Increasing political transparency
- Increasing protection of Australia's fresh water
- Increasing scrutiny of asylum seeker management
- Increasing scrutiny of unions
- Increasing support for rural and regional Australia
- Increasing support for the Australian film and TV industry
- Increasing support for the Australian shipping industry
- Increasing the cost of humanities degrees
- Increasing the diversity of media ownership
- Increasing the initial tax rate for working holiday makers to 19%
- Increasing the Medicare Levy to pay for the National Disability Insurance Scheme
- Increasing the price of subsidised medicine
- Increasing trade unions' powers in the workplace
- Increasing transparency of big business by making information public
- Increasing workplace protections
- Letting all MPs or Senators speak in Parliament (procedural)
- Letting environmental groups challenge the legality of certain government decisions
- Live animal export
- Making more water from Murray-Darling Basin available to use
- Market-led approaches to protecting biodiversity
- Net zero emissions by 2050
- Privatising certain government services
- Putting welfare payments onto cashless debit cards (or indue cards) on a temporary basis as a trial
- Putting welfare payments onto cashless debit cards (or indue cards) on an ongoing basis
- Re-approving/ re-registering agvet chemicals
- Reducing tax concessions for high socio-economic status
- Reducing the corporate tax rate
- Regional processing of asylum seekers
- Removing children from immigration detention
- Requiring every native title claimant to sign land use agreements
- Same-sex marriage equality
- Senate electoral reform
- Stopping people who arrive by boat from ever coming to Australia
- Stopping tax avoidance or aggressive tax minimisation
- Temporary protection visas
- The Australian Renewable Energy Agency (ARENA)
- The Coalition's new schools funding policy ("Gonski 2.0")
- The Paris Climate Agreement
- The territories being able to legalise euthanasia
- Tighter means testing of family payments
- Tobacco plain packaging
- Treating the COVID vaccine rollout as a matter of urgency
- Turning back asylum boats when possible
- Unconventional gas mining
- Vehicle efficiency standards
Divisions in which they voted the same
In divisions they have voted differently 2042 times. They have only voted the same 30 times.
-
-
edited 3rd Jul 2024
Motions - Middle East - Let another vote take place
Bert Van Manen voted No
Tanya Plibersek voted No
Not passed by a large majority
No rebellions 56% attendance
-
edited 5th Nov 2024
Financial Framework (Supplementary Powers) Amendment Bill 2024 - Report from Federation Chamber - Improved grants reporting
Bert Van Manen voted No
Tanya Plibersek voted No
Not passed by a modest majority
No rebellions 60% attendance
-
edited 23rd Jul 2024
Motions - Climate Change - Suspend the rules to let another motion be moved
Bert Van Manen voted No
Tanya Plibersek voted No
Not passed by a large majority
No rebellions 73% attendance
-
Bills — Migration Amendment (Removal and Other Measures) Bill 2024; Third Reading
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
No rebellions 77% attendance
-
edited 5th Apr 2024
Treasury Laws Amendment (Cost of Living Tax Cuts) Bill 2024 - Second Reading - Mr Bates' amendment
Bert Van Manen voted No
Tanya Plibersek voted No
Not passed by a large majority
No rebellions 62% attendance
-
edited 7th Jun 2024
Business - Consideration of Legislation - Increase speaking time for first Opposition speaker
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
No rebellions 76% attendance
-
edited 23rd Jun 2024
Business - Rearrangement - Put the question
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
No rebellions 64% attendance
-
edited 4th Feb 2024
Public Health (Tobacco and Other Products) Bill 2023 - Report from Federation Chamber - Close loopholes
Bert Van Manen voted No
Tanya Plibersek voted No
Not passed by a large majority
No rebellions 70% attendance
-
edited 26th Jan 2024
Motions - Climate Change: Threat and Risk Assessment - Let a vote happen
Bert Van Manen voted No
Tanya Plibersek voted No
Not passed by a large majority
No rebellions 58% attendance
-
edited 23rd Dec 2023
Environment Protection (Sea Dumping) Amendment (Using New Technologies to Fight Climate Change) Bill 2023 - Consideration in Detail - Agree with the bill
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
No rebellions 53% attendance
-
edited 30th Nov 2023
Environment Protection (Sea Dumping) Amendment (Using New Technologies to Fight Climate Change) Bill 2023 - Second Reading - Agree with the bill's main idea
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a modest majority
No rebellions 46% attendance
-
edited 4th Aug 2023
Constitution Alteration (Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice) 2023 - Third Reading - Pass the bill
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a modest majority
8 rebellions 97% attendance
-
edited 18th Aug 2023
Constitution Alteration (Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice) 2023 - Consideration in Detail - Agree with the bill
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a modest majority
8 rebellions 97% attendance
-
edited 4th Aug 2023
Constitution Alteration (Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice) 2023 - Second Reading - Agree with bill's main idea
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a modest majority
8 rebellions 97% attendance
-
edited 11th Aug 2023
Jobs and Skills Australia Amendment Bill 2023 - Consideration in Detail - Independent selection process
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
No rebellions 61% attendance
-
edited 1st Sep 2023
Social Security (Administration) Amendment (Income Management Reform) Bill 2023 - Second Reading - Agree with the bill's main idea
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
No rebellions 67% attendance
-
edited 7th Apr 2023
Social Security (Administration) Amendment (Income Management Reform) Bill 2023 - Second Reading - Against compulsory income management
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
No rebellions 67% attendance
-
edited 17th Feb 2023
Housing Australia Future Fund Bill 2023 - Consideration in Detail - Review process in 2025
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
No rebellions 56% attendance
-
edited 12th Aug 2022
Climate Change Bill 2022, Climate Change (Consequential Amendments) Bill 2022 - Consideration in Detail - More ambitious targets
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
No rebellions 89% attendance
-
edited 12th Aug 2022
Climate Change Bill 2022, Climate Change (Consequential Amendments) Bill 2022 - Consideration in Detail - More ambitious targets needed
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
No rebellions 89% attendance
-
edited 12th Aug 2022
Public Sector Superannuation Salary Legislation Amendment Bill 2022 - Second Reading - Agree with bill's main idea
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
No rebellions 80% attendance
-
edited 5th Aug 2022
Australian Human Rights Commission Legislation Amendment (Selection and Appointment) Bill 2022 - Second Reading - Human Rights Commissioner for LGBTIQA+ people
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
No rebellions 85% attendance
-
edited 21st Oct 2022
Foreign Investment Reform (Protecting Australia's National Security) Bill 2020 and another - Second Reading - Foreign acquisition
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
No rebellions 42% attendance
-
edited 31st Jul 2020
Customs Amendment (Growing Australian Export Opportunities Across the Asia-Pacific) Bill 2019 - Consideration in Detail - ISDS clauses
Bert Van Manen voted No
Tanya Plibersek voted No
Not passed by a large majority
No rebellions 64% attendance
-
edited 18th Oct 2019
Motions - Casinos - Suspend the usual rules
Bert Van Manen voted No
Tanya Plibersek voted No
Not passed by a large majority
No rebellions 69% attendance
-
edited 22nd Aug 2019
Committees - Crown Casino Committee - Appointment
Bert Van Manen voted No
Tanya Plibersek voted No
Not passed by a large majority
No rebellions 87% attendance
-
edited 7th Nov 2014
Constitution Alteration (Local Government) 2013 - Third Reading - Pass the bill
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
2 rebellions 89% attendance
-
Bills — Defence Trade Controls Bill 2011; Consideration of Senate Message
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
No rebellions 69% attendance
-
Bills — Defence Trade Controls Bill 2011; Consideration of Senate Message
Bert Van Manen voted Yes
Tanya Plibersek voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
No rebellions 69% attendance