Education Services for Overseas Students Amendment (Quality and Integrity) Bill 2024 - Second Reading - Criticism of Government
Not passed by a small majority
No rebellions 95% attendance
Division last edited 7th Sep 2024 by mackay staff
The majority voted against an amendment introduced by Goldstein MP Zoe Daniel (Independent), which means it failed. The amendment would have placed a sunset clause on parts 7 and 8 of schedule 1.
According to the bills digest:
Parts 7 and 8 introduce new Ministerial powers to regulate the provision of education to overseas students. They include allowing the Minister, via legislative instrument and with the agreement of the Minister responsible for Vocational Education and Training (VET) to:
limit the enrolments of overseas students by provider, course or location, over a year
automatically suspend and cancel specified courses on the basis of systemic issues, their value to Australia’s skills and training needs and priorities, or if it is in the public interest.
Ms Daniel explained that:
I am yet to be convinced that the volume of foreign students coming to Australia is the core of the problem that the government is trying to solve here, that they are the primary cause of the housing and rental crises currently besetting our country and causing so much hardship to so many. Nor am I convinced that, even if that is a major problem, this legislation is the way to solve it. Overseas student numbers collapsed during COVID, understandably, and now it seems to me that we're seeing a temporary spike as numbers recover.
(1) Page 2 (after line 12), after clause 3, insert:
4 Sunsetting of Parts 7 and 8 of Schedule 1
(1) Despite item 53 of Schedule 1, the amendments made by Part 7 of Schedule 1 do not apply in relation to the 2027 calendar year and later calendar years.
(2) Despite item 56 of Schedule 1, the amendments made by Part 8 of Schedule 1 cease to apply after the end of the 2-year period starting at the commencement of that Part.
Nobody rebelled against their party.
Party | Votes | |
---|---|---|
Australian Greens (75% turnout) | 3 Yes – 0 No | |
Stephen Bates Brisbane | Yes | |
Max Chandler-Mather Griffith | Yes | |
Elizabeth Watson-Brown Ryan | Yes | |
Adam Bandt Melbourne | Absent | |
Australian Labor Party (56% turnout) | 0 Yes – 43 No | |
Michelle Ananda-Rajah Higgins | No | |
Jodie Belyea Dunkley | No | |
Matt Burnell Spence | No | |
Linda Burney Barton | No | |
Josh Burns Macnamara | No | |
Alison Byrnes Cunningham | No | |
Lisa Chesters Bendigo | No | |
Jason Clare Blaxland | No | |
Sharon Claydon Newcastle | No | |
Libby Coker Corangamite | No | |
Mary Doyle Aston | No | |
Justine Elliot Richmond | No | |
Carina Garland Chisholm | No | |
Luke Gosling Solomon | No | |
Julian Hill Bruce | No | |
Ged Kearney Cooper | No | |
Jerome Laxale Bennelong | No | |
Sam Lim Tangney | No | |
Zaneta Mascarenhas Swan | No | |
Emma McBride Dobell | No | |
Louise Miller-Frost Boothby | No | |
Brian Mitchell Lyons | No | |
Rob Mitchell McEwen | No | |
Daniel Mulino Fraser | No | |
Shayne Neumann Blair | No | |
Brendan O'Connor Gorton | No | |
Alicia Payne Canberra | No | |
Graham Perrett Moreton | No | |
Fiona Phillips Gilmore | No | |
Sam Rae Hawke | No | |
Gordon Reid Robertson | No | |
Dan Repacholi Hunter | No | |
Tracey Roberts Pearce | No | |
Joanne Ryan Lalor | No | |
Marion Scrymgour Lingiari | No | |
Sally Sitou Reid | No | |
David Smith Bean | No | |
Anne Stanley Werriwa | No | |
Susan Templeman Macquarie | No | |
Kate Thwaites Jagajaga | No | |
Maria Vamvakinou Calwell | No | |
Josh Wilson Fremantle | No | |
Tony Zappia Makin | No | |
Anthony Albanese Grayndler | Absent | |
Anne Aly Cowan | Absent | |
Chris Bowen McMahon | Absent | |
Tony Burke Watson | Absent | |
Mark Butler Hindmarsh | Absent | |
Jim Chalmers Rankin | Absent | |
Andrew Charlton Parramatta | Absent | |
Julie Collins Franklin | Absent | |
Pat Conroy Shortland | Absent | |
Mark Dreyfus Isaacs | Absent | |
Cassandra Fernando Holt | Absent | |
Mike Freelander Macarthur | Absent | |
Steve Georganas Adelaide | Absent | |
Andrew Giles Scullin | Absent | |
Patrick Gorman Perth | Absent | |
Ed Husic Chifley | Absent | |
Stephen Jones Whitlam | Absent | |
Matt Keogh Burt | Absent | |
Peter Khalil Wills | Absent | |
Catherine King Ballarat | Absent | |
Madeleine King Brand | Absent | |
Tania Lawrence Hasluck | Absent | |
Andrew Leigh Fenner | Absent | |
Richard Marles Corio | Absent | |
Kristy McBain Eden-Monaro | Absent | |
Clare O'Neil Hotham | Absent | |
Tanya Plibersek Sydney | Absent | |
Amanda Rishworth Kingston | Absent | |
Michelle Rowland Greenway | Absent | |
Bill Shorten Maribyrnong | Absent | |
Meryl Swanson Paterson | Absent | |
Matt Thistlethwaite Kingsford Smith | Absent | |
Tim Watts Gellibrand | Absent | |
Anika Wells Lilley | Absent | |
Rebekha Sharkie Mayo Centre Alliance | Absent | |
Mark Coulton Parkes Deputy Speaker | Absent | |
Kate Chaney Curtin Independent | Yes | |
Zoe Daniel Goldstein Independent | Yes | |
Helen Haines Indi Independent | Yes | |
Monique Ryan Kooyong Independent | Yes | |
Sophie Scamps Mackellar Independent | Yes | |
Allegra Spender Wentworth Independent | Yes | |
Zali Steggall Warringah Independent | Yes | |
Kylea Tink North Sydney Independent | Yes | |
Andrew Wilkie Clark Independent | No | |
Russell Broadbent Monash Independent | Absent | |
Andrew Gee Calare Independent | Absent | |
Dai Le Fowler Independent | Absent | |
Bob Katter Kennedy Katter's Australian Party | Absent | |
Liberal National Party (0% turnout) | Absent | |
Angie Bell Moncrieff | Absent | |
Colin Boyce Flynn | Absent | |
Cameron Caldwell Fadden | Absent | |
Garth Hamilton Groom | Absent | |
Henry Pike Bowman | Absent | |
Phillip Thompson Herbert | Absent | |
Andrew Wallace Fisher | Absent | |
Andrew Willcox Dawson | Absent | |
Terry Young Longman | Absent | |
Liberal Party (3% turnout) | 0 Yes – 1 No | |
Jason Wood La Trobe | No | |
Karen Andrews McPherson | Absent | |
Bridget Archer Bass | Absent | |
Scott Buchholz Wright | Absent | |
David Coleman Banks | Absent | |
Peter Dutton Dickson | Absent | |
Warren Entsch Leichhardt | Absent | |
Paul Fletcher Bradfield | Absent | |
Ian Goodenough Moore | Absent | |
Andrew Hastie Canning | Absent | |
Alex Hawke Mitchell | Absent | |
Luke Howarth Petrie | Absent | |
Simon Kennedy Cook | Absent | |
Julian Leeser Berowra | Absent | |
Sussan Ley Farrer | Absent | |
Nola Marino Forrest | Absent | |
Melissa McIntosh Lindsay | Absent | |
Zoe McKenzie Flinders | Absent | |
Ted O'Brien Fairfax | Absent | |
Tony Pasin Barker | Absent | |
Gavin Pearce Braddon | Absent | |
Melissa Price Durack | Absent | |
Rowan Ramsey Grey | Absent | |
James Stevens Sturt | Absent | |
Michael Sukkar Deakin | Absent | |
Angus Taylor Hume | Absent | |
Dan Tehan Wannon | Absent | |
Bert Van Manen Forde | Absent | |
Ross Vasta Bonner | Absent | |
Aaron Violi Casey | Absent | |
Jenny Ware Hughes | Absent | |
Rick Wilson O'Connor | Absent | |
Keith Wolahan Menzies | Absent | |
National Party (8% turnout) | 0 Yes – 1 No | |
David Gillespie Lyne | No | |
Sam Birrell Nicholls | Absent | |
Darren Chester Gippsland | Absent | |
Pat Conaghan Cowper | Absent | |
Kevin Hogan Page | Absent | |
Barnaby Joyce New England | Absent | |
Michelle Landry Capricornia | Absent | |
David Littleproud Maranoa | Absent | |
Michael McCormack Riverina | Absent | |
Llew O'Brien Wide Bay | Absent | |
Keith Pitt Hinkler | Absent | |
Anne Webster Mallee | Absent | |
Milton Dick Oxley Speaker | Absent | |
Totals (38% turnout) | 11 Yes – 46 No |
Turnout is the percentage of members eligible to vote that did vote.