Therapeutic Goods Amendment (Repeal of Ministerial Responsibility for Approval of Ru486) Bill 2005 - Second Reading - Bill unacceptable
Not passed by a small majority
No rebellions 97% attendance
The majority voted against amendments introduced by Liberal MP Andrew Laming.
These amendments opposed the main purpose of this bill, which is to remove ministerial responsibility for approval of RU486 and related medicines. Instead, the amendments would have made some changes to the current process but fundamentally kept it in place. In other words, ultimate responsibility for approving RU486 would remain with the Minister. Senator Laming explained that his amendment ensures that Parliament will continue to have oversight over this controversial issue.(Read Mr Laming's full explanation and the associated debate here. )
This division was a conscience vote, meaning that members were not required to vote along party lines.
Background to the bill
The bill was introduced to amend the Therapeutic Goods Act 1989 in order to transfer the responsibility for regulatory approval of RU486 from the Minister for Health and Ageing to the Therapeutic Goods Administration. This will make it possible to evaluate, register, list or import abortifacients such as RU486 (i.e. medicines intended to induce an abortion) for use in Australia without the approval of the Minister.(Read more about the bill in its bills digest (342 KB). More information, including its explanatory memorandum, is available here.)
Nobody rebelled against their party.
Party | Votes | |
---|---|---|
Australian Labor Party (98% turnout) | 5 Yes – 53 No | |
Tony Burke Watson | Yes | |
Anthony Byrne Holt | Yes | |
Chris Hayes Werriwa | Yes | |
John Murphy Lowe | Yes | |
Gavan O'Connor Corio | Yes | |
Dick Adams Lyons | No | |
Anthony Albanese Grayndler | No | |
Kim Beazley Brand | No | |
Arch Bevis Brisbane | No | |
Sharon Bird Cunningham | No | |
Chris Bowen Prospect | No | |
Anna Burke Chisholm | No | |
Ann Corcoran Isaacs | No | |
Simon Crean Hotham | No | |
Michael Danby Melbourne Ports | No | |
Graham Edwards Cowan | No | |
Justine Elliot Richmond | No | |
Annette Ellis Canberra | No | |
Kate Ellis Adelaide | No | |
Craig Emerson Rankin | No | |
Laurie Ferguson Reid | No | |
Martin Ferguson Batman | No | |
Joel Fitzgibbon Hunter | No | |
Peter Garrett Kingsford Smith | No | |
Steve Georganas Hindmarsh | No | |
Jennie George Throsby | No | |
Steve Gibbons Bendigo | No | |
Julia Gillard Lalor | No | |
Sharon Grierson Newcastle | No | |
Alan Griffin Bruce | No | |
Jill Hall Shortland | No | |
Michael Hatton Blaxland | No | |
Kelly Hoare Charlton | No | |
Julia Irwin Fowler | No | |
Harry Jenkins Scullin | No | |
Duncan Kerr Denison | No | |
Catherine King Ballarat | No | |
Carmen Lawrence Fremantle | No | |
Kirsten Livermore Capricornia | No | |
Jenny Macklin Jagajaga | No | |
Robert McClelland Barton | No | |
Bob McMullan Fraser | No | |
Daryl Melham Banks | No | |
Brendan O'Connor Gorton | No | |
Julie Owens Parramatta | No | |
Tanya Plibersek Sydney | No | |
Roger Price Chifley | No | |
Bernie Ripoll Oxley | No | |
Nicola Roxon Gellibrand | No | |
Kevin Rudd Griffith | No | |
Bob Sercombe Maribyrnong | No | |
Stephen Smith Perth | No | |
Warren Snowdon Lingiari | No | |
Wayne Swan Lilley | No | |
Lindsay Tanner Melbourne | No | |
Kelvin Thomson Wills | No | |
Maria Vamvakinou Calwell | No | |
Kim Wilkie Swan | No | |
Rod Sawford Port Adelaide | Absent | |
Dave Tollner Solomon Country Liberal Party | Yes | |
Ian Causley Page Deputy Speaker | Yes | |
Bob Katter Kennedy Independent | Yes | |
Peter Andren Calare Independent | No | |
Harry Quick Franklin Independent | No | |
Tony Windsor New England Independent | No | |
Liberal Party (99% turnout) | 41 Yes – 31 No | |
Tony Abbott Warringah | Yes | |
Kevin Andrews Menzies | Yes | |
Mark Baker Braddon | Yes | |
Bob Baldwin Paterson | Yes | |
Phillip Barresi Deakin | Yes | |
Kerry Bartlett Macquarie | Yes | |
Bronwyn Bishop Mackellar | Yes | |
Alan Cadman Mitchell | Yes | |
Steven Ciobo Moncrieff | Yes | |
Alexander Downer Mayo | Yes | |
Trish Draper Makin | Yes | |
Peter Dutton Dickson | Yes | |
Pat Farmer Macarthur | Yes | |
David Fawcett Wakefield | Yes | |
Michael Ferguson Bass | Yes | |
Gary Hardgrave Moreton | Yes | |
Joe Hockey North Sydney | Yes | |
John Howard Bennelong | Yes | |
Greg Hunt Flinders | Yes | |
David Jull Fadden | Yes | |
Michael Keenan Stirling | Yes | |
Jackie Kelly Lindsay | Yes | |
Andrew Laming Bowman | Yes | |
Jim Lloyd Robertson | Yes | |
Louise Markus Greenway | Yes | |
Sophie Mirabella Indi | Yes | |
Chris Pearce Aston | Yes | |
Christopher Pyne Sturt | Yes | |
Don Randall Canning | Yes | |
Kym Richardson Kingston | Yes | |
Andrew Robb Goldstein | Yes | |
Philip Ruddock Berowra | Yes | |
Alby Schultz Hume | Yes | |
Patrick Secker Barker | Yes | |
Peter Slipper Fisher | Yes | |
Alex Somlyay Fairfax | Yes | |
Wilson Tuckey O'Connor | Yes | |
Malcolm Turnbull Wentworth | Yes | |
Danna Vale Hughes | Yes | |
Ross Vasta Bonner | Yes | |
Barry Wakelin Grey | Yes | |
Fran Bailey McEwen | No | |
Bruce Baird Cook | No | |
Bruce Billson Dunkley | No | |
Julie Bishop Curtin | No | |
Russell Broadbent McMillan | No | |
Mal Brough Longman | No | |
Peter Costello Higgins | No | |
Warren Entsch Leichhardt | No | |
Teresa Gambaro Petrie | No | |
Joanna Gash Gilmore | No | |
Petro Georgiou Kooyong | No | |
Barry Haase Kalgoorlie | No | |
Stuart Henry Hasluck | No | |
Dennis Jensen Tangney | No | |
Michael Johnson Ryan | No | |
Sussan Ley Farrer | No | |
Peter Lindsay Herbert | No | |
Ian Macfarlane Groom | No | |
Margaret May McPherson | No | |
Stewart McArthur Corangamite | No | |
Judi Moylan Pearce | No | |
Gary Nairn Eden-Monaro | No | |
Brendan Nelson Bradfield | No | |
Geoff Prosser Forrest | No | |
Tony Smith Casey | No | |
Andrew Southcott Boothby | No | |
Sharman Stone Murray | No | |
Cameron Thompson Blair | No | |
Ken Ticehurst Dobell | No | |
Mal Washer Moore | No | |
Jason Wood La Trobe | No | |
Kay Elson Forde | Absent | |
National Party (91% turnout) | 7 Yes – 3 No | |
John Anderson Gwydir | Yes | |
John Forrest Mallee | Yes | |
De-Anne Kelly Dawson | Yes | |
Peter McGauran Gippsland | Yes | |
Paul Neville Hinkler | Yes | |
Bruce Scott Maranoa | Yes | |
Warren Truss Wide Bay | Yes | |
John Cobb Parkes | No | |
Luke Hartsuyker Cowper | No | |
Kay Hull Riverina | No | |
Mark Vaile Lyne | Absent | |
David Hawker Wannon Speaker | Absent | |
Totals (97% turnout) | 56 Yes – 90 No |
Turnout is the percentage of members eligible to vote that did vote.